Single Beat Combinations №15
What this trains
Beat 3 belongs to the left here and beat 4 to the right, which is the reverse of №14. That one change alters the shape of the bar more than a hand swap sounds like it should: the weaker hand's double now comes first, and the stronger hand's double closes the bar.
For a right-handed player the result is a crescendo where №14 produces the opposite. In №14 the right's double lands on beat 3 with everything it has and the left answers more quietly, so the bar tapers; reverse the order and the bar builds into the barline instead. Neither is what the exercise asks for. Play the two lines back to back and listen for whether the last four notes are louder or softer than the first four, because the direction of the error tells you which double is at fault.
The swap has a second effect that is easy to miss. The left now leads the four alternating strokes and then has to produce the double, so it is the busiest hand in the bar before the hardest thing in the bar arrives. If the LL is late as well as light, take the tempo down until its second stroke is one you decide on rather than one you receive.
Watch №15 played Jumps to this exercise · DDrummer project on YouTubeQuestions and problems
- My left double is fine on its own but not here.
- Because it does not arrive on its own. The left has led four alternating strokes before it, so it reaches beat 3 already working, with less height and less patience than it has from a standing start. Practise the last two beats alone, then add the first two back.
- The bar gets louder towards the end.
- The right's double on beat 4 is both the last thing in the bar and the easiest thing in it. Set the level for the whole bar from the left's double on beat 3 and bring the right down to meet it, not the other way round.
- Which of №14 and №15 deserves more time?
- Whichever one sounds different from the other. If the bar has the same shape either way round, they are done. If the second half changes character when the hands swap, the two doubles are not matched, and this is the version that shows it.